Callie vs TherapyNotes: Which EHR Fits Your Practice?

The decision is not whether TherapyNotes is a capable EHR. It is whether a system built for behavioral health fits the work of an SLP, OT, or PT practice. TherapyNotes serves psychologists, therapists, psychiatrists, social workers, billers, and schedulers well. Its strengths include psychotherapy documentation, insurance billing depth, published pricing, and 24/7 support. Callie serves SLP, OT, and PT practices from solo providers through multi-provider teams. It fits practices that want therapy-aware AI note drafts, recurring scheduling, patient communication, eligibility checks, and claims in one system. A behavioral-health practice should favor TherapyNotes. A rehab therapy practice should start with Callie unless TherapyNotes has a specific billing or support advantage that outweighs the discipline mismatch.

TherapyNotes is a mature, behavioral-health-specific EHR. It gives mental health practices structured notes, DSM-5 and ICD-10 diagnosis search, recurring scheduling, a branded client portal, telehealth, and deep clearinghouse tools. Its billing system supports primary and secondary claims, claim scrubbing, ERA posting, and paper claim mailing. Every plan includes 24/7 phone and email support, a 30-day trial, and free client-data import. Those are meaningful reasons for a behavioral-health practice to choose it.

TherapyNotes does not position itself for speech, occupational, or physical therapy. Its public documentation pages focus on psychotherapy progress notes, treatment plans, psychological evaluations, mental-status content, and behavioral-health diagnoses. An SLP, OT, or PT practice can customize templates, but it must test whether those templates support evaluation-heavy work and therapy CPT billing without repeated workarounds. Callie starts from SLP, OT, and PT workflows. Its AI Notetaker writes editable drafts into SOAP, Progress, Evaluation, Plan of Care, General, or custom templates. For a practice with pediatric caseloads, neither vendor claims pediatric-specific tooling, school billing, goal data collection, or a complete authorization workflow. Test those needs directly.

TherapyNotes is a cloud-based practice management and EHR platform built specifically for behavioral health. A psychologist and an information technology founder launched it in 2010 after developing an internal system for a mental health group practice. The vendor says thousands of providers use the product nationwide. Its public pages name psychologists, therapists, psychiatrists, social workers, and other mental health professionals as its audience.

The product has real depth inside that market. Notes support treatment plans, progress notes, psychological evaluations, intake notes, and Process Notes kept outside the medical record. The note builder uses dropdowns, checkboxes, text fields, DSM-5 and ICD-10 search, and prior-note history. TherapyFuel can draft SOAP progress notes from audio or a summary. It can also draft treatment-plan goals and client-history summaries.

Billing and support are the clearest reasons to choose TherapyNotes. The integrated clearinghouse reaches over 2,000 payers and checks eligibility with nearly 900 payers. It supports claim scrubbing, primary and secondary claims, paper claim mailing, ERA-assisted payment posting, statements, superbills, and aging reports. Every subscription includes 24/7 phone and email support. ChoosingTherapy scored its support, clinical documentation, and pricing transparency at the top of the review scale. TherapyNotes also publishes HITRUST certification and includes basic telehealth, unlimited clients, appointments, notes, and storage on every plan.

TherapyNotes fits when the practice is primarily behavioral health, even if it also handles family schedules and insurance billing. Its portal supports intake, appointment requests, secure messages, and bill pay. Its calendar handles recurring appointments, provider filters, location filters, and unavailable time. Premium Telehealth adds sessions for up to 16 participants. A group psychotherapy practice can use these features without adapting a rehab system to mental health work.

The mismatch begins with the clinical model. TherapyNotes does not name SLP, OT, or PT on the reviewed home, pricing, documentation, or company pages. Its named templates center on mental health treatment plans and psychological evaluations. Its diagnosis tools center on DSM-5 and ICD-10. The public pages do not establish articulation, fluency, dysphagia, sensory-processing, or motor templates. They also do not establish SLP, OT, or PT goal-trial data collection. A practice that writes many evaluations should rebuild its two hardest notes during the trial and time them.

A pediatric caseload adds tests, but it does not change either vendor’s positioning. ChoosingTherapy reports that specialty templates for families and pediatric practices can require manual workarounds. The same review describes the calendar as dated, with no drag-and-drop rescheduling and limited bulk actions. It also reports limited custom reporting and visual analytics. These are review themes, not universal outcomes. Test a school holiday, one make-up visit, one guardian message, and a multi-provider calendar before assigning weight to them.

Insurance depth cuts the other way. TherapyNotes has claim scrubbing and ERA posting that Callie does not claim in its software. SoftwareAdvice summarizes reports from some reviewers about claims marked sent that did not reach the payer, so a buyer should test rejection and status handling. Neither product publishes a complete authorization visit-limit workflow. Callie’s eligibility response can state that prior authorization is required, but it does not claim visit-limit tracking. Keep authorization counts in the evaluation as a shared test, not a claimed win for either product.

Callie begins with the disciplines TherapyNotes does not name. It supports SLP, OT, and PT practices from solo clinicians through multi-provider teams. The AI Notetaker accepts a session recording, a voice memo, or typed shorthand. It writes a draft into SOAP, Progress, Evaluation, Plan of Care, General, or a custom template. Articulation, Language, and Fluency templates tune the draft to treatment. The clinician reviews every word, edits it, and signs it. The authorship ledger records who created, edited, and finalized the note.

The schedule connects the recurring appointment to reminders, video, payment, and claim status. Callie sends email and text reminders before each session, including a morning reminder and a final message 30 minutes before the start. Google Calendar sync sends sessions out and brings busy blocks in. Patients can request appointments and manage rescheduling. Every appointment can carry attendance, payment, and claim status. Multi-provider organizations can view every provider in one grid and share patients under practice rules.

For insurance work, Callie runs real-time eligibility checks across 3,400+ payers through Stedi. Its AI Summary converts the payer response into coverage, the speech therapy copay, remaining deductible, and prior-authorization requirement. Staff build a claim queue from completed insurance appointments and submit selected rows. Clearinghouse statuses return to the appointment with an event timeline. Callie also creates superbills from past appointments. It does not claim claim scrubbing, ERA posting, denial management, appeals, or modifier automation in the software.

Patients and families use a portal for secure messages, intake forms, saved payment methods, and appointment management. Callie calls this a patient portal, not a parent portal. The product is not pediatric-specific and does not claim school billing, a home program builder, or goal progress graphs. Those omissions matter for some practices. The relevant advantage is a direct SLP, OT, and PT foundation, not a claim that every therapy workflow is present.

A mixed behavioral-health and rehab practice has the hardest decision because each product starts from a different clinical model. Build the trial around the discipline with the most complex evaluations and the payer workflow with the highest revenue risk. Compare the complete TherapyNotes cost, including add-ons and transaction fees, with the Callie plan that contains the features you need. Use the therapy practice software evaluation guide to score the same scenarios in both systems.

Export before you give notice. Collect signed notes, treatment plans, evaluations, patient demographics, appointments, uploaded files, insurance records, claims, payments, statements, and audit history. Open samples from every export instead of trusting a file count. Ask the new vendor which fields it imports and which records remain documents. Keep the old system available until the first claim cycle and patient-balance reconciliation are complete.

For a pediatric caseload, cut over at a natural school-year boundary when possible. Rebuild recurring appointments after accounting for holidays and confirm every family’s contact and portal access. Sign the new vendor’s business associate agreement before patient information enters the account. The therapy EHR migration checklist provides a staged plan for exports, testing, training, and the final cutover.

“

“Choose TherapyNotes for behavioral-health depth. Choose Callie when SLP, OT, or PT work defines the practice.”